9-2-2019 ‘Zionism is at the core of Jewish identity, so anti-Zionism is anti-Semitic’ — A response – Joseph Levine Mondoweiss

 https://mondoweiss.net/2019/09/zionism-identity-response/

 

…for Pearl and many Zionists the point isn't to defend Zionism at all.  The point is to structure the public debate so that criticisms of Zionism cannot be aired in the first place.  Pearl wants critics of Zionism to be prohibited from making their arguments on the grounds that doing so would violate the identity-rights of Jews.  But if he admits, as I imagined he would, that identity-rights can't immunize a genuinely-unjust doctrine from public criticism, how do you prohibit criticism of Zionism in the public realm until you've shown that it's not unjust?  And how do you do that if you don't allow those who claim it is unjust to make their case publicly?  It seems as if there's a Catch-22 here.  If it's morally kosher, then Zionism cannot be legitimately criticized because of its role in Jewish identity.  But we can't know if it's morally kosher unless we subject it to the critique of anti-Zionists first, which, according to Pearl's argument, we're not allowed to do…

 

Posted by Judith Ferster, AIME member

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

10-30-2013 Israel's Weapons Industry, Arms Trade and Military and Surveillance Co-operation with the European Union – Shir Hever (economic researcher at Alternate Information Center) ePalestine

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeDFEoKEi8Y The European Union is Israel's most important trading partner. An increasingly important part of that trade is in goods and services of the defense and homeland security industries. These have become a pillar of Israel's economy, and also play a big role in a number of EU countries. Israel touts its "battle-proven" technologies such as electronics and drones used in surveillance and assassinations, as well as the expertise and equipment it uses to repress popular resistance activities in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. In Europe, France and the United Kingdom are among the world's premier arms exporters -- including to Israel. Germany and Italy are also significant in this respect, with the former providing submarines (capable of being refitted for nuclear weapons...
Read more

8-15-2018 Bennett rejects potential truce deal with Hamas as ‘reward for terrorists’ Michael Bachner Times of Israel

https://www.timesofisrael.com/bennett-rejects-potential-truce-deal-with-hamas-as-reward-for-terrorists/ Jewish Home leader says his party will oppose any long-term ceasefire accord, warns it harms Israel's deterrence; defense minister dismisses 'empty slogans'… A key coalition ally of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday harshly criticized any deal for a long-term ceasefire between Israel and the Hamas terror group in the Gaza Strip, adding that ministers in his party will oppose it. "Liberman's gestures to efense officials took part in the meeting, Liberman's office said… This week, Israeli authorities noted a significant drop in incendiary kite and balloon attacks f Palestinian enclave.   Senior Israel officials maintain the country has not agreed to the ceasefire that Hamas announced late Thursday and said went into effect at midnight. Hamas, a terror group that seeks to destroy Israel, claims the deal was mediated by Egypt and other ...
Read more

Black lawmakers vow to stand by Israel despite sitting out Netanyahu speech

http://www.jta.org/2015/03/10/news-opinion/politics/black-lawmakers-vow-to-stand-by-israel-despite-sitting-out-netanyahu "Leading black lawmakers have taken pains to put the blame for the speech incident on Boehner and convey their continued support for Israel. At the news conference with Lewis, Rep. G.K. Butterfield (D-N.C.), the caucus chairman, described a phone call he had with Ron Dermer, the Israeli ambassador to Washington who organized the invitation with Boehner, and who agreed to Boehner's request to keep it secret from the president and congressional Democrats. "During that telephone conversation I pleaded with the ambassador to seek a postponement of the joint session, but he dismissed that idea," Butterfield said. "Notwithstanding, I pledged my continued personal support and explained that Israel has many friends in the Congressional Black Caucus, and do not think that Speaker Boehner's conduct will interfere with our relationship." Posted ...
Read more